Family Handyman

Removing old or damaged fence posts can seem daunting. Many homeowners wrestle with posts that refuse to budge, especially those anchored firmly in concrete. Removing fence post sections may not always require back-breaking labor. If you go about it with the proper methods and tools, your fence post removal project will be successful without inflicting any damage to you or your surroundings.

Common Challenges in Fence Post Removal

Fence posts can be difficult to remove when they are deeply embedded, encased in a hefty concrete footing or made of wood that has rotted at ground level, making it difficult to get a good grip. Soil type also plays a significant role. Dense clay can hold a post much more tenaciously than sandy soil.

Sometimes, the biggest challenge is performing the fence post removal without damage to nearby plants, pathways, or the fence panels you intend to reuse. Identifying these potential issues upfront will help you choose the best way to remove fence post elements in your specific situation.

Tools You’ll Need for Fence Post Removal

Having the right equipment is crucial for an efficient and safe DIY fence post extraction.

  • Safety gear: Use heavy-duty gloves, glasses or goggles and sturdy, closed-toe footwear. Hearing protection is also recommended if you are using power tools.
  • Shovel and/or post hole digger: These are used to dig around the post to expose the footing or loosen the soil. A tile spade can be useful for narrow areas or cutting small roots.
  • Digging bar/pry bar: A long, heavy metal bar provides excellent leverage for prying posts loose.
  • Leverage aides: A piece of scrap 2×4 lumber and a sturdy block (like landscape timber) can act as a fulcrum.
  • Reciprocating saw (e.g., sawzall): Useful for cutting through old nails, attaching fence rails or even cutting off a stubborn post at ground level if outright removal proves too difficult.
  • Post puller or jack system (optional): For deeply embedded or heavily concreted posts, tools like a T-post puller, a high-lift jack with chains or specialized fence post pullers can be invaluable and offer a significant mechanical advantage.
  • Wheelbarrow: For hauling away the old post, concrete and debris.

When working with concreted fence posts, we recommend loosening the surrounding soil first to make the removal process much smoother. Sometimes, simply digging around the concrete base and using a heavy pry bar with a good fulcrum is the best way to remove fence post sections without resorting to heavy machinery.

Step-by-Step Guide to Removing Fence Posts (The Mike Barnes Method)

One of the best post-pulling techniques comes from Family Handyman reader Mike Barnes, who says, “I’ve tried a lot of different methods for removing 4×4 fence posts sunk in concrete, but this fence post removal strategy is the easiest one I’ve found. Screw a piece of scrap 2×4 to the post a couple of inches from the ground, put a landscape timber alongside as a fulcrum and use a long metal bar as a lever. Just stand on the bar and the post and concrete footing will usually pop right out of the ground.”

Execute this method by following the steps below.

1. Prepare the area and assemble materials

  • Clear the area around the post, removing any plants or objects that could be damaged or obstruct your work.
  • If fence panels are attached, carefully detach them from the post you intend to remove. You might need to cut nails with a reciprocating saw.
  • Gather your tools: scrap 2×4, landscape timber (or similar sturdy block for a fulcrum) and a long metal pry bar.

2. Get a grip on the post

Securely screw a piece of scrap 2×4 horizontally to the fence post a few inches above ground level. This will give your lever something substantial to push against.

3. Weaken or wet the base (If necessary)

  • For posts heavily embedded in soil or concrete, digging around the top of the concrete footing or soaking the ground thoroughly with water a day in advance can help loosen the soil’s grip. You can feel the resistance lessen as the soil loosens around the post’s base, making it easier to tug free with minimal effort.
  • Exposing the top edges of the concrete can give better leverage points when removing cemented fence posts or show how extensive the footing is.

4. Lift with Leverage

  • Place your landscape timber (fulcrum) on the ground alongside the post, close to the attached 2×4.
  • Position the long metal pry bar so that one end is under the secured 2×4 on the post, and the bar rests across the fulcrum.
  • Apply downward pressure to the other end of the pry bar. Standing on the bar often provides enough force. The post and its concrete footing should start to lift or pop out of the ground. You may need to adjust the fulcrum position or dig a bit more for particularly stubborn posts. This technique is a great example of effective DIY fence post extraction.
  • On a tricky fence replacement project, we find that using a heavy-duty car jack (ensure you know how to jack up a car safely) and a strong chain securely wrapped around the post (or the concrete base if accessible) works wonders for lifting deeply embedded posts set in concrete.

5. Remove and fill

  • Once the post and footing are out, carefully remove them from the area.
  • Backfill the hole properly with soil, tamping it down in layers to prevent settling. If you’re installing a new post in the same spot, follow appropriate guidelines for DIY fence installation tips.

Tips for Removing Cemented Fence Posts

Dealing with removing cemented fence posts often requires extra effort.

  • Dig around the concrete: The first step is to dig around the concrete footing to fully expose its size and shape. This reduces soil friction against the concrete.
  • Break up large footings (if necessary): For large concrete footings that won’t budge with leverage alone, you might need to break up parts of the concrete with a sledgehammer carefully. Always wear safety glasses and heavy gloves for this. However, this can be labor-intensive.
  • Water power: As mentioned, soaking the soil around the concrete can help. For some, using a pressure washer with a narrow nozzle to blast away soil around the concrete can expedite the process.
  • Wiggle and pull: Once some space is created, try to wiggle the post and footing to break any remaining soil adhesion before attempting to lift.

Dealing With Rotted or Damaged Fence Posts

Removing a rotted post presents a unique challenge because the wood might break off when you try to apply force.

  • Reinforce the post: If the post is rotted at ground level but solid higher up, you might be able to screw sturdy wood planks (e.g., 2x4s) on two or four sides of the post, extending from the solid wood down past the rotted section and ideally into the concrete or deep soil. This gives you something solid to leverage against.
  • Dig out the footing: If the post breaks off completely, your focus shifts to removing the remaining stump and concrete footing. This usually means more digging to get leverage directly on the footing.
  • Specialized tools: Tools designed for removing cemented fence posts, like concrete post pullers, might be necessary as they can grip the concrete directly.

FAQ

Is it possible to pull out fence posts without heavy machinery?

Yes, absolutely! Many posts, even those in concrete, can be removed using manual methods like the lever technique. The key is using leverage effectively. This is often the preferred method for DIY fence post extraction.

Can I do a DIY fence post extraction if I’m not very strong?

Yes. While some strength is helpful, many effective methods emphasize using leverage and the right tools for lifting fence posts, not just brute force. A longer lever bar, a well-positioned fulcrum, or a mechanical aid like a jack can multiply your effort significantly.

Sources