Save on Pinterest

Surprise, Surprise These 20 Old Tools Are Worth Big Bucks

You won't believe what the most expensive tool in the world sold for at auction.

1 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Nicholson Molding Plane

Francis Nicholson is America’s first documented planemaker because it’s believed he became the first planemaker to imprint his name on the tools he created. Nicholson lived from 1683-1753 and this wooden plane sold for $5,140 at auction. Check out some of our favorite woodworking tools.

2 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Norris Jointer Plane

Thomas Norris made precision planes in England because he worked with exotic woods. Few of his planes survived through war and have become valuable for their rarity and their utilitarian value. This plane fetched $12,250 at auction.

Check out how to plane rough-sawn lumber with a jointer and a planer.

3 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Tidey Patent Beveling Plane

Milton B. Tidey created an elaborate beveling plane that is a marvel for collectors because of its complex design. This one grabbed $8,970 at auction. Find out why having a power planer is a great tool.

4 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Adams Patent Patternmaker’s Plane

The uniqueness of this bronze plane drove its value up to $19,550 at auction. It wasn’t a super useful tool because it required switching out parts for specific functions that could be done with existing tools.

Learn the 10 tool myths you have to stop believing.

5 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Davis Patent Double Inclinometer

Leonard Davis created several inclinometers to measure angles but this double inclinometer is special because it has two levels. The rarity of this one helped drive the price to $8,165 at auction. Make sure your level is on the level by checking it with these tips.

6 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Davis Patent Level

Another Leonard Davis creation, this one grabbed the attention of collectors and non-collectors at auction because of the ornate design. It went for $2,310. Learn how you’ve been hanging pictures wrong and how you can change it.

7 / 20
Michael J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Gunmetal Miller Patent No. 50

Charles Miller came up with this plane, which would’ve cost a cabinetmaker two months salary to buy when it was patented in 1872. It was only offered for a year and its rarity pushed its price up to $18,650 at auction. Check out a modern day planer and what you can do with one.

8 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: C.E. Chelor Cornice Molding Plane

This cornice molding plane was made by Cesar Chelor, a former slave of Francis Nicholson, who was freed after Nicholson’s death. Chelor became Nicholson’s apprentice and continued to create tools throughout his life. He is the earliest documented African American toolmaker in America. This particular plane garnered $27,950 at auction because it dates back to the 1730s or 1740s and it came in unused condition.

Just getting into woodworking? Get started with these easy-to-follow tips for beginning woodworkers.

9 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Carpenter Patent Plow Plane

Emanuel W. Carpenter of Lancaster, Pennsylvania became adept at creating innovative tools and his plow plane has become a coveted item. It sold for $17,600 at auction and it’s a unique tool because it has a handle in the back. Find out how to pick out rough sawn lumber quickly and easily.

10 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Hovey Family Tool Chest

This tool chest is a bit of a history lesson, too. It belonged to the Hovey family and contained not only the patriarch’s tools but also the family’s history. The tool chest dates back to the 19th century and traveled with the family from New Hampshire to Ohio. It sold for $14,950 at auction. Discover the best tool storage tips out there.

11 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Miller Patent Plane No. 42 Type 1

Charles Miller made patterns and castings from toys in addition to planes. Stanley eventually took over this elaborate and elegant plane. It’s a gunmetal bronze alloy and it sold for $19,800 at auction. Sometimes you can find a fortune in the attic, just like these 14 times someone found a fortune in an attic.

12 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Ohio No. 1 C Smoothing Plane

Few plane makers made a No. 1 plane because of its small size — it’s only 5 1/2-inches long. Ohio Tool was the only company to come up with a corrugated sole in the No. 1 size and there are believed to only be one or two examples, Donnelly said. If any of these items are sitting in your attic, you could be sitting on a goldmine.

13 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Engraved Victorian Calipers

This set of calipers from the Victorian era caught $4,510 at auction because of the superior condition they came in. If you need calipers quickly, here’s a simple fix for you.

14 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Patent Gold-Plated Ivory Handle Presentation Wrench

This wrench was supposed to be a gift to Chauncey Depew, an attorney for Cornelius Vanderbilt’s railroad interests who later became president of the New York Central Railroad System and a U.S. Senator from New York. It’s a gold-plated, ivory-handled wrench with one standout feature. Depew’s name is misspelled on it. It fetched $5,980 at auction. Keep your wrenches straight with one simple trick.

15 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Chaplin Patent Plane

A Chaplin No. 1 plane is a rare item and considered one of the planes every collector wants, Donnelly said. This one went for $7,700. Find out how to properly use a block plane for your next project.

16 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Antique Woodworking Tools: Vertical Post Plane

Leonard Bailey patented several planes before Stanley finally bought him out after a series of patent fights. His designs are still used today. His was one of the first to build metallic planes and this plane sold for $7,920. Keep your tools in great shape with one special ingredient.

17 / 20
Martin J. Donnelly Auctions

Leonard Bailey Patent Bronze Scraper

This bronze scraper is thought to be the only one of its kind around made by Leonard Bailey, Donnelly said. It sold for $32,200 and is believed to have been created during Bailey’s early development. Start refurbishing furniture after reading this how-to guide.

18 / 20
Live Auctioneers

Broom Vise

This broom vise sold at a 2008 auction for $275. Not a bad haul for something that was probably just sitting around an old barn. Clean faster around the home by ditching a broom.

19 / 20
Trice Auctions

John Deere Wrench

Yes, a wrench went for $16,500 at an auction in 2017. The reason it’s so valuable is that it is a wrench for John Deere tractor that the company tried to take out of circulation. It’s believed that there are just nine wrenches total in the world left to the Dain all-wheel drive, four-cylinder, three-wheel tractor. It’s unknown how many tractors exist after John Deere made just 100 of the model and repurchased nearly all of them. The tractors were sold primarily in the Dakotas. D. Wayne Dill purchased the wrench in 2009 for $15,000. See what you need to do to keep your tractor running great.

20 / 20
MJD Tools

Rodier’s Patent Models and Drafting Set

In the world of antique tool collecting, this drafting set and patent model of Louis C. Rodier holds the world record price for a tool. It sold for $91,000 at auction in 2004. The previous record for a tool was just $30,000 at the time.

What makes this item unique is that it is the personal model of Rodier and his drafting set. The tool itself is unique because of its design and high level of “gizmosity,” according to auctioneer Martin J. Donnelly. Add these great 100 shop tips to your shop for easier work.