Step 1: Measure the old door and order the new one
Photo 1: Pry off the interior trim
Robin thought this was a pretty neat trick. Protecting the wall with a putty knife under the pry bar meant she wouldn’t have to repaint the entry.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
One of the biggest mistakes homeowners make is to grab a door off the home center shelf and expect it to fit right. So my first coaching task was to help Robin and Danny measure for and order the door. First we measured the width and height of the door. Then Robin carefully pried off the interior trim (Photo 1) so we could measure the rough opening, which is the width between the studs and the height from the floor to the header.
“Protecting the wall with a putty knife saved the wall paint. Neat trick!”
Next we measured from the back of the outside trim, or brick molding, to the face of the interior wall to find the jamb width. Ordering the new door with the right jamb width ensures that the interior trim fits without the need for added jamb extensions. Finally we went back outside and measured the width from the outside of the brick molding and the height from the bottom of the sill to the top of the exterior trim. To avoid having to patch siding, it’s best to order a door assembly that will fill the space. This may mean asking for special exterior trim that’s wider than standard 2-in.-wide “brick molding.” If you’re ordering a door and sidelight(s), you can adjust the width by substituting a different size sidelight or by adjusting the space between the door and the sidelight. The door and sidelight were assembled at the plant and arrived as a single unit. Installation of a door without a sidelight is the same.
With the door size, jamb width and dimensions of the rough and exterior opening in hand, Robin and Danny went door shopping. They discovered that the standard configuration of a 3-ft. door and sidelight was a few inches too narrow and 1/2 in. shorter than their existing door and sidelight. The salesperson recommended spending a little extra money to add a spacer between the door and the sidelight. This corrected the width problem. Robin and Danny could have ordered a custom height door and frame for several hundred dollars more, but they decided to live with the height difference and cover the gap with trim later. We decided to add a strip of plywood under the sill to raise the door slightly, so in the end the shorter height worked out perfectly.
“I was shocked at all the door options available. The choices were limitless.”
Robin and Danny wanted a door that looked like wood, minus the maintenance hassles. They chose a Therma-Tru fiberglass door with a surprisingly realistic-looking oak wood grain. The cost of the door and sidelight unit was $1,300. Fortunately (for us, anyway!), the door assembly plant wasn’t too busy and the door was delivered about 10 days later.
Step 2: Remove the old door
Photo 2: Tear off the brick molding
Danny cut the caulk along the edges of the brick molding with a utility knife so it would be easier to remove. But the molding was still stubborn and came off in pieces.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 3: Free the door frame
Here’s Robin with her brand new recip saw cutting through the nails so the door frame will come out easily. She’s looking forward to the next demolition project so she can hone her sawing skills.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 4: Remove the old frame
Danny didn’t have any trouble getting the frame out after removing the trim and cutting the nails and screws. The sill was stuck down with caulk, but broke free as Danny tilted the frame.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Robin was surprised at how easy the door and frame were to remove, especially after the interior and exterior trim were off (Photos 1 and 2). And she got to learn a new skill—operating a reciprocating saw (Photo 3). If you don’t have a recip saw, you can use a hacksaw blade.
Step 3: Prep the opening
Photo 5: Check the sill
Robin was a lot more flexible than Danny, so he let her do most of the low work. Here she’s checking the sill area to make sure it’s level. They’ve already added a layer of plywood to raise the door a little.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Working in older houses or where the door is exposed to the weather, I often have to repair a water damaged subfloor or otherwise rebuild the sill area before installing the new door. In this case, the subfloor was in good condition, but we noticed that the new door sill was thinner than the old one. After taking a few measurements, we decided to add a strip of plywood over the subfloor to raise the door so it would clear the entry rug (Photo 5). Robin checked to be sure the sill area was level. We could have shimmed under the plywood with strips of building paper or scrap vinyl flooring to level the floor if necessary.
Since our door was covered by an overhanging roof, we didn’t need additional protection from water, but if you install a door that’s exposed to the weather, be sure to add a sill pan to protect the subfloor (one brand is Jamsill Guard, jamsill.com) and a metal drip cap over the exterior trim.
Step 4: Set the new door in place
Photo 6: Caulk the opening
Danny’s done a lot of caulking, so this part was easy. He inspected the bottom of the door frame and did some measuring to be sure the beads of caulk aligned with flat spots on the sill. When Danny finished caulking the sill, he caulked around the perimeter of the opening too.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 7: Set the door frame
Robin and Danny could rest easy now. The door frame slid into the opening as planned and the heavy-lifting part of the job was done.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
With the old door out and the opening prepared, we were ready to install the new door and sidelight. Before we started, I explained to Robin and Danny that our goal was to set the new door frame in the opening and then adjust it with shims until the door fit perfectly. First we removed all the packing material from the new door and hoisted it into the opening to check the fit. The width was a little tight. We didn’t have much wiggle room between the siding and the brick molding, but it was obvious we could make it work. So we removed the door unit and Danny applied heavy beads of polyurethane caulk to the sill and exterior sheathing (Photos 6 and 7). Danny and Robin moved the door to the opening and tilted it into place (Photo 7).
Step 5: Shim, square and fasten the frame
Photo 8: Tack the top corners
Here Robin is trying out her nailing skills. The 16-penny nails proved a bit much, though, so Danny took over the nailing duty.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 9: Plumb the hinge side
Robin was a natural with the level, so she’s checking to make sure the jamb is plumb while Danny makes adjustments from the inside.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 10: Shim the door frame
Danny slid pairs of shims behind the hinges and along the sidelight on the opposite side. He positioned the shims to create an even gap around the door.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 10A: Close-up of shims
Use pairs of shims to bridge gaps.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Photo 11: Secure the frame with screws
After checking to make sure the door was contacting the weather stripping evenly and operating smoothly, Danny drilled countersink holes and drove 3-in. screws through the jamb at each shim location. To secure the hinge side, he removed one short screw from each hinge and replaced it with a long screw.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
Now we were ready to tack it in and add shims. Shimming a door is the most critical part of the installation since it’s when you tweak the frame to make the door fit perfectly and operate smoothly. I helped Robin and Danny center the top of the door frame with an equal caulk space between the siding and the trim on each side, and then tack the two top corners with 16d galvanized casing nails, letting the heads stick out so we could make adjustments later if necessary (Photo 8).
Next, Robin held a level to the hinge-side trim while Danny pried on the frame until the jamb was plumb (Photo 9). We drove another nail at the bottom of the hinge-side jamb to hold the frame plumb. With the door temporarily tacked in place, Danny and I headed around through the back door with a couple of bundles of wood shims. I gave him pointers as he wedged pairs of shims behind the hinges and along the top and far side of the frame. The goal was to create an even gap between the door and the frame (Photo 10). The key to shimming is to look at the gap between the door and the frame, and then decide how you can wedge the frame to correct any problems. We spent about 45 minutes adjusting shims before we were satisfied with the way the door fit.
“I didn’t know that shimming a door was such a fussy, time-consuming job.”
Nails through the exterior trim hold the door frame temporarily, but they don’t offer enough support to keep the door square over time. For that we still needed to drive 3-in. screws through the jamb and into the wall framing (Photo 11). We drove the screws at the shim locations to hold the shims in place and avoid bending the jamb. Then Danny set the nails that we had left sticking out and added nails about 16 in. apart along the exterior trim. After Danny completed this step, he made one final check of the door’s fit in case adjustments were needed before we added insulation and reinstalled the interior trim.
Step 6: Add the finishing touches
Photo 12: Seal the shim space
Danny was experienced with spray foam, so he handled this task admirably. He managed to fill the space between the jamb and the framing with foam without getting it all over the place.Photo: Courtesy of The Family Handyman
It was a relief to have the door securely installed. Robin and Danny relaxed, knowing they could lock the door for the night. I didn’t have to warn Danny about the dangers of squirting too much expanding foam into the space around the door (Photo 12). He’d already learned that the hard way. With the space between the door and the frame well sealed and insulated, we moved to the outside, where we fitted a piece of trim over the door and caulked around the brick molding to seal the exterior. Now all that was left to do was install new interior trim, finish the door and install the new handle and lock.
Required Tools for this Project
Have the necessary tools for this DIY project lined up before you start—you’ll save time and frustration.
- Caulk gun
- Countersink drill bit
- Drill/driver - cordless
- Hearing protection
- Level, 4-ft.
- Pry bar
- Putty knife
- Reciprocating saw
- Safety glasses
- Tape measure
Required Materials for this Project
Avoid last-minute shopping trips by having all your materials ready ahead of time. Here’s a list.
- Door latch and lock
- Galvanized casing nails, 16d
- Minimum expanding foam
- New door
- Polyurethane caulk
- Screws, 3-in.
- Wood shims