Family Handyman Guide to Replacing Your Garage Door

Boost curb appeal and maybe even security with new garage doors. Find out cost ranges and other important details here.

Brought to you by

A garage that faces the street (especially a large two- or three-car garage) can take up a lot of visual real estate. If your garage doors are in poor shape, clash with the style of your home or are just uninspired, replacing them can greatly increase your home’s curb appeal. Here are the need-to-know facts about updating your garage doors, covering style, cost and more.

Craftsman Garage by Saussy Burbank

Updating your garage doors can enhance your home’s curb appeal, and in the case of attached garages, make your home more secure.

When’s the Best Time to Replace Old Garage Doors?

Since it is outdoor work, it is ideal to replace garage doors during warm, dry weather. That said, unless you are painting or installing a more elaborate custom feature (like a pergola), the weather does not matter too much — as long as it’s not freezing and you’re not in the middle of a thunderstorm, your pro should be able to tackle the job in a few hours.

large craftsman style garage door upgrade
Traditional Garage by Polhemus Savery DaSilva

Who to hire: Because of the precision required, installing a new garage door is best left to the pros. A garage door professional will have the most experience and expertise at fitting and installing your garage door.

Permit required? Maybe. Because it is essentially an exterior wall, some cities do require a permit for replacing a garage door and opener. Any reputable pro that you hire should be able to tell you whether or not you will need a permit for the work; if you are still not sure, contact your city or county government agency and ask.


  • Wood offers the widest range of design options and works well in all climates; it is the most expensive.
  • Steel is typically less expensive than wood, but because it can rust, it should be avoided in coastal areas.
  • Aluminum costs more than steel but does not rust, making it a good choice for coastal homes.
  • Tempered glass in an aluminum or wood frame is well suited to modern and contemporary homes.
  • Fiberglass and vinyl are budget-friendly options and will not rust, but design choices may be limited and these materials can crack in cold weather. Here’s everything you need to know about fiberglass and vinyl garage doors.
modern sliding garage door revamp
Contemporary Garage by Estes/Twombly Architects, Inc.

Door types:

  • Sectional: The most common type of garage door; rolls up and down on tracks.
  • Sliding: Barn-style garage doors (as shown here) slide open to the side, requiring a wider garage wall to accommodate the door when open.
  • Swing-out. Double doors that swing outward when open are not a good choice for cold climates, as snow drifts can block the doors from opening.

All of these door types can be made in a manual or automatic, remote-operated version.

How Long Does It Take To Upgrade Garage Doors?

If you are purchasing a standard-size garage door and it is in stock, it could be ready as soon as the next day. Custom doors may take a month or two to arrive. Once you have your new door, a pro can have it installed it in a single morning.

modern garage door remodel
Contemporary Garage by mark pinkerton – vi360 photography

How Much Does Updating Garage Doors Cost?

Steel garage doors typically range in price from $300 to $3,000; glass with an aluminum frame costs $1,500 to $3,000; vinyl costs $600 and up; fiberglass costs $1,500 and up. Wood doors are typically the most expensive, $1,000 to $10,000. Installation costs vary by region, but you can expect to pay roughly $100 to $200 to remove and dispose of your old garage door, and another $100 to $500 for a pro to install your new one. A pergola over garage doors can run $5,000 to $8,000 installed.

For a smaller update, new sconces cost $100 and up each, plus installation; new hardware costs from $5 up to $100 or more per piece, depending on the materials used. Painting or staining can be done as a DIY project for only the cost of materials.

upgrading garage doors to craftsman style
Craftsman Garage by Todd Soli Architects

How to Choose Your Replacement Garage Doors

It’s best to match your garage door to the style of your home, so seek one out that echoes the architectural features, materials and colors of the rest of your home. For example:

  • Pair a traditional home with an arched garage door with paned windows.
  • Update your Spanish colonial with a wooden garage door with iron hinges.
  • Add a rustic barn-style garage door to your farmhouse.
  • Accent a Craftsman home with a wooden garage door with rectilinear windows and trim.
  • Match up a modern home with a sleek glass-paned garage door.
white traditional garage doors
Traditional Garage by Lasley Brahaney Architecture + Construction

Once you have chosen your new garage doors, consider which accents would best complete the look. Decorative corbels beneath the eaves add character to this garage, pulling in some of the style of the house.

upgraded garage doors
Traditional Garage by Three River Stone

If your garage roof does not have eaves deep enough to fit corbels, a pergola with arched brackets can create a similar look.

newly replaced garage doors
Traditional Garage by Siemasko + Verbridge

Sconces and hardware are other finishing touches that can make a big impact. Or, if you do not want to replace your garage doors, simply adding attractive sconces, new hardware and a fresh coat of paint or stain can revive your garage on a budget.