Wood Router Reviews

Best midsize wood routers

If you’re in the market for a new router, you’re in luck. Selection, prices, features—and the routers themselves—are better than ever. But having a wider selection and variety of features also makes choosing a router more complicated than it used to be. And that’s the reason for this article.

By the DIY experts of The Family Handyman Magazine

We review nine popular midsize wood routers and pick our favorites

We’ll focus on “midsize” routers in the 1-1/2 to 2-1/4 hp range. Routers of this size are the do-anything utility players in most shops, powerful enough to spin the biggest bits but small enough for comfortable handling. It’s nice to have a bigger router mounted in a router table and a smaller “trim” router for light-duty work, but every woodworker needs the versatility of a midsize model. And if you plan to own only one router, midsize is the best choice by far. We selected models in a variety of price ranges and put them to the test. Here’s what we learned.

Skil 1817 fixed-base router

Hp/Amps: 1-3/4 hp/9.5 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: No

This router has what it takes to do 90 percent of your routing tasks at a very good price. You get some nice-to-have features such as a micro-adjustment and constant speed. At 9.5 amps, this is the lowest-amp router in our collection, which sometimes means making an extra pass or two when using the bigger bits.

Reasonably priced and can do most jobs you’ll face.
Back to Top

Two collets are better than one

Router bit shanks come in 1/4- and 1/2-in. diameters. (There are also 3/8-in. shanks, but they’re very rare.) Usually, you can get the same bit with a shaft of either size. But some small bits are available only with 1/4-in. shafts, while some large bits require 1/2-in. shafts. Most routers on the market today—including all the models we tested—come with collets to handle both sizes.

Drill Master 68341 fixed-base router

Hp/Amps: 2 hp/11 amps

Collet Size: 1/4”, 3/8” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: No

A simple combination of low cost and high power makes this router a genuine bargain. It even has some extras like a spindle lock for easier bit changes and a micro-adjustment feature. Our only gripe is the lack of variable speed.

Lots of power for not a lot of bucks.
Back to Top

Fixed-base or plunge?

A fixed base is simple: You just set the depth of cut and rout. You can do the same thing with a plunge base by locking in the depth. Or of course you can plunge. The legs on a plunge router are kind of like shock absorbers: Push down and the legs compress. That means you can lower the bit while it spins. And that allows you to start your cut in the middle of a surface, rather than only along an edge.

This power to plunge lets you do things you couldn’t (or shouldn’t) do with a fixed base: cut stopped flutes or dadoes, mortises or engravings. Despite that extra versatility, most router aces told us their plunge routers mostly sit on the shelf. One pro woodworker summed it up this way: “My fixed-base routers are simpler, easier to set up and adjust. So I only use a plunge when I have to—and that’s about once a year.”

Porter-Cable 690 fixed-base router

Hp/Amps: 1-3/4 hp/11 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: No

This simple, dependable workhorse has been a pro favorite for decades. But it lacks many of the refinements found on some other pro-grade routers, such as above-the-table height adjustment for router tables.

A classic, but missing some features found in other
pro-grade routers.
Back to Top

Consider a combo kit

Can’t decide between fixed-base and plunge? You don’t have to. Most manufacturers now offer “combo kits” that give you one motor along with both a fixed and a plunge base. You truly get the best of both worlds. But do the math before you buy. In some cases, the extra cost of a combo kit is more than the cost of a second good-quality router.

Ridgid R2200 fixed-base router

Hp/Amps: 2 hp/11 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: Yes

This router can handle any routing task and has lots of extras, big and small: above-the-table height adjustment, constant speed with rpm spelled out on the dial, soft start, micro-adjustment, even built-in LED worklights.

Good power and lots of features.
Back to Top

Beware of horsepower ratings

Take the horsepower rating on any power tool with a grain of salt. It’s not that the manufacturer is lying—it’s just that there are no consistent industry standards for determining horsepower. So it’s better to squint at the specifications and find the amp rating. The amp rating isn’t a perfect indicator either, but it’s more reliable than horsepower. The routers we tested ranged from 9 to 13 amps. Other routers range from about 3 amps in the tiniest trim routers to 15 amps in the biggest wood-hogging beasts.

Milwaukee 5615-20 fixed-base router

Hp/Amps: 1-3/4 hp/11 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: No

This is an excellent pro-grade router with above-the-table height adjustment and micro-adjustment. And we love the unique adjustable strap that allows for comfortable one-hand operation.

Pro-grade router with excellent features.
Back to Top

Variable speed is essential for big bits

Variable speed is a feature that’s pointless most of the time, but mandatory at other times. In most cases, you want the bit spinning as fast as the router can go, and adjusting the speed wouldn’t make sense. With large-diameter bits, however, full speed isn’t safe (check the rpm restrictions on the label). So if your plans include big bits, choose a variable-speed router.

Some routers also offer constant speed, which keeps the rpm stable under load. When you’re running at full speed, this feature isn’t much of an advantage. But when you dial down the rpm to use a large bit, the router senses the load and feeds more power to maintain the speed set on the dial. It’s not essential, but it’s a nice feature that prevents running at slower speeds than you intended.

Skil 1830 combo-base router

Hp/Amps: 2-1/4 hp/10 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: Yes

This is a great combo kit at a great price and includes easy-to-use micro-adjustment on both bases, soft start and LED light. It lacks above-the-table height adjustment, though.

Great features at a great price.
Back to Top

Above-the-table height adjustment

If your router will spend a lot of time in a router table, this is a feature you’ll love. Just insert a shaft through the top of the table and crank the router up or down. No more struggling to adjust the depth of cut from below.

Craftsman 27683 combo-base router

Hp/Amps: 2 hp/12 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: Yes

This package offers the highest amp rating in our roundup and a ton of features like above-the-table height adjustment, constant speed, soft start, micro-adjustment on the fixed base and LED lights. And all of that at a fantastic price.

Very nice features-to-dollars ratio.
Back to Top

Micro-adjustment

Adjust the bit height in increments of 1/64 in. or less simply by turning a ring or a knob. This precision means you’ll make far fewer test cuts and readjustments before you get the height right.

DeWalt DW616PK combo-base router

Hp/Amps: 1-3/4 hp/11 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: No

This is a rugged, pro-grade kit, heavy-duty and well-engineered top to bottom, but it lacks some nice-to-have features like above-the-table height adjustment.

Good, solid pro-grade router, but lacks a few features.
Back to Top

Easy-access power

Turning a router on or off without letting go of the handle is quick and convenient, and safer for you and your project. To accomplish this, many plunge routers have a trigger mounted right on the handle, and some fixed-base models have a switch within finger’s reach of the handle.

Ryobi 180-PL plunge-base router

Hp/Amps: 2 hp/10 amps

Collet Size: 1/4” and 1/2”

Variable Speed: Yes

If a pure plunge router is what you’re looking for, this model gets the job done at a good price. As with many other plunge routers, the base is not removable, so bit changes are a bit more cumbersome.

Reasonably priced pure plunger.
Back to Top

Dust collection

Capturing router dust is difficult, and of the models we tried, none do it very successfully. For this reason, woodworkers we talked to rarely bother to connect a vacuum to their routers. Still, some do appreciate dust collection when routing that dreaded dust demon, MDF.

Back to Top

Why the Family Handyman editors love their routers

Back to Top