• Share:
Choosing the Best Power Generator

We outline the pros and cons of two types of emergency electrical generators—the portable type and the larger standby type—and tell you how to decide between them.

By the DIY experts of The Family Handyman Magazine

Choosing the Best Power Generator

We outline the pros and cons of two types of emergency electrical generators—the portable type and the larger standby type—and tell you how to decide between them.

Emergency generators: Two options

With the American power grid becoming less reliable every year, power outages are bound to occur more frequently and last longer. That means you could end up sitting in the dark, sweating without an air conditioner, and eating canned meals while $300 worth of food spoils in your freezer. Meanwhile, your basement could flood since the sump pump is now worthless—and your kids could go crazy without a TV or computer.

Power grid problems aside, we all lose electricity occasionally. But when outages become routine, leaving you without electricity for days on end, it’s time to take action by getting a generator. Smaller, portable generators are great for powering the essentials, like the refrigerator and microwave, while large standby generators can power everything in your house.

In this article, we’ll walk you through both types of generators (portable and standby) and both ways to deliver backup power (extension cords and subpanels). We’ll cover the pros and cons of each system and give you an idea of prices.

Portable generator

Photo courtesy of Briggs & StrattonPortable generator

Standby generator

Photo courtesy of Briggs & StrattonStandby generator

Two Types of Generators, Two Very Different Costs

1. Portable
When the power goes out, you have to start up a gas-powered portable generator and plug it into your appliances or a subpanel. Portable generators cost $500 to $1,500 depending on power output.

2. Standby
These generators are powered by natural gas or propane and start automatically during power outages. Prices start at $5,000 for a 7,000-watt unit, including installation.

How to determine what size generator you need

Your first step in adding backup power is deciding what you need (or want) to keep running when the electricity goes out. This determines the size (wattage) of the generator you’ll need.

Walk through the house and make a list of everything you want to power during an outage. Look for a label on each appliance (they have to have one) that contains information such as wattage, model number and the year it was made (photo). Some labels are right inside the door on appliances; others are on the back, so you have to pull the appliance away from the wall. Write down the item and how much wattage it uses. Be sure to include essential items, like refrigerators, freezers, a well pump if you have one, and a sump pump if your basement could flood. You can go a few hours or even days without an oven (use the microwave instead) and an air conditioner—they use a lot of power and would require you to buy a much bigger generator.

Add together the items’ wattages, then multiply that number by 1.5 (appliances need the extra power to start up). That’s the minimum wattage needed for your generator.

Wattage Requirements

Microwave: 600 to 1,200 watts

Refrigerator: 700 to 1,200 watts

Freezer: 500 to 1,200 watts

Washing machine: 1,200 watts

1/3-hp sump pump: 800 watts

Television: 300 watts

Laptop computer: 250 watts

10,000-Btu air conditioner: 1,500 watts

Option 1: Plug-in generators

The most basic method of supplying backup power is running a portable generator in your yard, then plugging in extension cords that plug into your appliances. It’s also the least expensive solution since you don’t need to hire an electrician to install a subpanel. The downside is you have to run extension cords everywhere you want power and you’re limited to how many things you can plug in at once (most generators have either two or four outlets). You also have to start and maintain the generator.

When the power goes out, place the generator on a flat surface outside, at least 10 ft. from the house. Don’t set it under awnings, canopies or carports, or inside the house or garage. It’s absolutely critical that you keep the generator away from your house and especially away from doors and windows—your life could depend on it! More people die from carbon monoxide poisoning from the gas engines on generators than from the disasters causing the power outages.

Caution:
Plug in a carbon monoxide detector when using a portable generator. It’ll alert you if generator exhaust reaches a dangerous level inside the house.

Extension cords must be at least 14 gauge to carry adequate power. Follow the cord’s maximum wattage rating (listed on the cord’s label). Start up the generator, then plug in the extension cords (photo above). Be careful not to overload the generator by plugging in high-wattage appliances that you didn’t plan for. It’ll trip the breaker or blow a fuse on the generator, or damage the appliance motors.

Portable generators range in price from $500 for a 3,250-watt unit to $1,500 for a 10,000-watt unit. Options include wheels (get them—generators are very heavy to lift) and electric (key) starts rather than pull-starts. Consider how long the generator can run on a tank of gas. Some run just a few hours, so you’ll have to get up in the middle of the night to add fuel. Others have 16-gallon fuel tanks that can run up to 10 hours.

Figure A: Portable generator with transfer switch panel

Figure A: Portable generator with transfer switch panel

A Manual Transfer Switch Panel Makes Portable Power More Convenient

To use a portable generator without the hassle of running extension cords, hire an electrician to install a manual transfer switch subpanel off your main circuit panel and install a dedicated inlet to power the subpanel (installing the subpanel is complex; not a DIY project). This setup gives you the advantage of powering entire circuits in the house, not just individual appliances. The drawback is you still have to start and maintain the gas-powered generator. And unless you buy a large generator (they’re available with more than 15,000 watts), you’re still limited in what you can power.

Before calling an electrician to add the subpanel, choose what you want to power during an outage. It’s worth including a circuit that’ll let you run your TV, computer and a lamp, especially if you lose power for days at a time, so you can keep everyone entertained. Plus, these electronic devices don’t require a lot of wattage. The circuits you want powered will be moved from your main circuit panel to your subpanel, so they’ll run when you have normal power and when you lose electricity and hook up the generator. Expect to pay $200 for materials and at least $500 for an electrician to install the subpanel and special inlet.

During a power outage, run a cord from the generator to the inlet, flip a manual transfer switch on the subpanel, and all the designated circuits will have power. Choose a heavy-duty extension cord (photo above left) with twist-lock ends (generators have receptacles for these ends) that stay in place once they’re plugged into the generator and inlet. Be sure to keep the generator at least 10 ft. from the house.

Caution!

Don't attach a second male end to a power cord, then run it from the generator to a wall outlet to power a circuit (yes, people have done this). This may seem like a clever way to run power through your home's wiring system, but the electricity will run back through the circuit breaker panel and out to the utility lines, which can kill service personnel working on the lines, even if they’re miles away.

Option 2: Standby generators

Standby generators automatically turn on when the power goes out—you don’t have to do a thing. This is the best option if you frequently lose electricity and want to keep all or most of your appliances running. Most standby generators are powerful enough to run a central air conditioner, kitchen appliances and other large items—simultaneously. They’re also quieter than portable generators and you don’t need to worry about running cords or storing gasoline. The drawback is the price. You’ll need to have the generator, transfer switch and subpanel professionally installed.

A transfer switch constantly monitors power. If you lose electricity, it starts the generator automatically—even if you’re not home. When power is restored, the transfer switch shuts off the generator.

Standby generators connect to your home’s fuel supply (natural gas or propane). If you don’t already have one of these fuel lines coming into the house, install a propane tank.

Standby generators range from $5,000 for a 7,000-watt unit to more than $15,000 for a 30,000-watt unit (installation included). Home centers carry a limited selection of portable generators (but usually no standby units). Larger sizes and standby units are usually available through special order or from the manufacturer.

Figure B: Standby generator system

Figure B: Standby generator system

Standby Generator System

Standby generators run off your home's natural gas supply or a propane tank, which can be underground. The transfer switch automatically starts the generator, which powers the circuits in the subpanel.

Back to Top

Comments from DIY Community Members

Share what's on your mind and see what other DIYers are thinking about.

1 - 6 of 6 comments
Show per page: 20   All

June 03, 2:43 AM [GMT -5]

If you’re planning on a portable generator you may want to think about chaining it to a secure object. You may wake with no heat and no generator

March 28, 2:31 PM [GMT -5]

My house on Connecticut's Fabulous Vacation Shoreline is heated by two Vermont Castings propane stoves, therefore, I have the big tan and hose runs for propane, and the tank is right near where the electrical service comes in the house.

I also have sleep apnea, and the big storm in 2011 left us without power for 11 days, and left ME with an uvula five times it's normal size. I was thinking about a car-rechargeable backup battery and inverter for my CPAP machine (which inverts and transforms 110-120 VAC @ 50-60 Hz, with a i Amp max draw, to 12 VDC w/3.0 Amp max draw), but the gold-standard fix is a generator.

Any ideas, hints, tips, whatever on propane-powered generators?

Thanks for your help!

Bart Brown

November 08, 1:10 PM [GMT -5]

I disagree on the estimated cost of the material regarding the installation of a generator subpanel. I have priced the cost of the material needed and it far exceeds two hundred dollars. I have priced the material at the big box stores as well as an electrical supply house. I have found that the realistic cost of the materials is five hundred dollars.

It would be great if someone came up with an idea of how to protect these portable generators from rain/snow. Most people wheel these units out of their garages and place them a minimum of 10' away from their homes. The generator is now in the elements. I had a heavy duty cover that I use and I secure it with a tie down strap rachett. I leave the exhaust exposed. The down side is when the generator needs to be refueled. I have to removed everything to refuel. I do like the idea of using an old door and 3" closet flanges secured to the underside of the door. The legs being 3" PVC and installing a 3" PVC Tees near the bottom of the legs. Installing an additional piece of 3" PVC as a cross brace will give you a spot to place a sand bag over the cross member to hold down the shelter. This way you can atleast protect your generator from a direct hit from rain or snow and be able to refuel



March 20, 6:04 PM [GMT -5]

I'm surprised that you didn't mention furnaces. In the majority of the country a day or two without an operating furnace is more than an inconvenience. It can cause a destructive calamity from frozen/bursting pipes. If it freezes in your area, please consider the power requirement of your furnace, and make the furnace circuit an absolute priority.
On the subject of heating during a power outage, running extension cords through a window is rather ineffective when you're trying to maintain heat in the house. The window won't fully close.

LLO

March 19, 12:47 PM [GMT -5]

WHY DON'T YOU INCLUDE THE OPTION OF POWERING YOUR ENTIRE MAIN PANEL WITH THE PORTABLE GENERATOR BY ADDING A GENERATOR BREAKER AND AN INTERLOCK KIT www.interlockkit.com. I USE THIS METHOD AND IT LETS ME CHOOSE WHICH BREAKERS I WANT TO POWER TO SUIT MY NEEDS AT ANY ONE TIME. I AM AN ELDERLY WOMAN AND HAVE HAD NO PROBLEMS AT ALL IN USING THIS METHOD DURING POWER OUTAGES. LINEMEN ARE PROTECTED SINCE THE INTERLOCK KIT MAKES IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR THE MAIN PANEL SWITCH TO BE "ON" WHEN THE GENERATOR BREAKER IS "ON".

March 19, 12:43 PM [GMT -5]

How about an article and comparison of the various portable emergency generators on the market. I've heard horror stories about various brands but Honda is SO expensive. I'd like to get a good, reliable, unit this year.

Another thing: Power typically goes out in a rain storm and you want it "at least 10 feet" from the house. How about a shelter for the generator? Can i run the generator in the garage with an "exhaust pipe extension" like they use at the car repair shop in the winter (Minnesota)?

+ Add Your Comment
closeX

Add Your Comment

Choosing the Best Power Generator

Please add your comment
closeX

Log in to My Account

Log in to enjoy membership benefits from The Family Handyman.

  • Forgot your password?
Don’t have an account yet?

Sign up today for FREE and become part of The Family Handyman community of DIYers.

Member benefits:

  • Get a FREE Traditional Bookcase Project Plan
  • Sign up for FREE DIY newsletters
  • Save projects to your project binder
  • Ask and answer questions in our DIY Forums
  • Share comments on DIY Projects and more!
Join Us Today
closeX

Report Abuse

Subject
Reasons for reporting post

Free OnSite Newsletter

Get timely DIY projects for your home and yard, plus a dream project for your wish list!

Follow Us

Featured Product

Buy Now