• Share:

Comments from DIY Community Members

Share what's on your mind and see what other DIYers are thinking about.

1 - 7 of 7 comments
Show per page: 20   All

January 15, 8:42 PM [GMT -5]

Big question here...Please help me out.

My experience, seeing my dad and relatives reseat toilets, is to put the wax ring ON THE FLOOR, then place the bolts, then seat the toilet.

When I went to get a new wax seal for leaks, I got told PUT THE SEAL ON THE TOILET FIRST, then place on the floor...

Which is right ???

September 04, 2:19 AM [GMT -5]

I am a contractor and agree on everything in this install with the exception of the shims. Using one of The Family Handyman toilet install tips linked below:
This is a great tip and usually eliminates the need for shims. Just put the bowl in place without the wax ring of course, and then tape on the floor around the bowl. Remove the bowl and caulk around the inside edge of the tape template. And be liberal with the caulking it should push out and can be cleaned up after. This usually self levels the toilet. The only drawback with this method is you should not use the toilet for about 24 hours so the caulking can harden.

September 03, 2:54 PM [GMT -5]

Wax seal? give me a break-the waxless one's are so much better.

September 03, 8:50 AM [GMT -5]

I like TeXan's suggestion #4 about leaving the back uncaulked for leak detection. This way you have the best of both worlds; a solid connection to the floor (not to mention a cleaner looking job) but also the ability to detect leaks.

March 10, 6:19 PM [GMT -5]

Holmes on Homes from HGTV insists one never caulks the toilet to the floor for the reason that you want to be able to see if there is a leak, especially when the toilet is mounted on a wood floor. Should the seal leak, the caulk would contain the leak resulting in rot of the wood fooring or more damage if it is on an upper floor.

January 01, 11:19 AM [GMT -5]

Nic article most common cause of sewage smell in bathroom is a failed wax seal.

1. The toilet flange should be ABOVE the finished floor. not even with it. If it is too low add shims to raise it to the correct level.
2. Most plumbers would recommend that the wax seal not have the built in plastic horn or funnel in it .. Just plain wax.
3. Waxless toilet seals can work but are more prone to failure. I like the Fernco branc myself
4. I like to caulk around the base with a non silicone caulk Leave the back open to detect a leak if it would occur. (it seals the toilet to the floor) I use poly seam seal. silicone sticks too much to the floor. Just a little caulk will do. Some like to use plaster of paris or plumbers putty at the toilet floor interface.
5. make sure you check to make sure the toilet has not been leaking and the subfloor or joists rotted. if rotted, they should be repaired first!
6 Toilet recommendations. I like a gravity flush with larger flush valve and fully glazed trapway. all major manufacturers make them now. Look at some plumber chat sites.. ie plbg.com for name recommendations..

December 21, 1:50 PM [GMT -5]

you advise to caulk around the toilet base after it has been put in place and shimmed. i thought conventional wisdom was that you don't caulk around the base in order to be able to see any leakage that may be happening at the wax riing or flange. with the base caulked the leak won't show, with potentially damaging consequences. how say you.....

+ Add Your Comment

Add Your Comment

How to Replace a Toilet

Please add your comment

Log in to My Account

Log in to enjoy membership benefits from The Family Handyman.

  • Forgot your password?
Don’t have an account yet?

Sign up today for FREE and become part of The Family Handyman community of DIYers.

Member benefits:

  • Get a FREE Traditional Bookcase Project Plan
  • Sign up for FREE DIY newsletters
  • Save projects to your project binder
  • Ask and answer questions in our DIY Forums
  • Share comments on DIY Projects and more!
Join Us Today

Report Abuse

Reasons for reporting post

Free OnSite Newsletter

Get timely DIY projects for your home and yard, plus a dream project for your wish list!

Follow Us