• Share:
Painting: How to Choose and Use Primers

Three painting pros recommend the best primers to solve common painting problems, including stains on walls, moisture damage, old painted surfaces, odors, color changes and new exterior wood.

By the DIY experts of The Family Handyman Magazine

Overview: The benefits of primer

One of the most powerful tools in any pro painter's arsenal is what goes underneath the paint—primer. Primer is an excellent problem-solver that's less like paint and more like glue. It sticks to whatever you're prepping and turns it into a smooth, uniform surface that's ready for paint.

But if you've ever walked down the primer aisle at a home center, you know the primer choices are mind-boggling. To cut through the clutter, we asked three professional painters, each with 20-plus years of experience, to give us their recommendations for the best primers to use for common painting challenges. Their experience will help you choose the best primer for the job, so your paint will look better and last longer.

Problem 1: Interior stains and odors

Some stains will bleed right through most primers and paints no matter how many coats you apply. The same goes for severe odors like smoke from fires and cigarettes.

The solution is stain-blocking primer, which is available in oil-based (alkyd) and water-based (acrylic-latex) versions. Oil-based versions give off a nasty smell and require paint thinner for cleanup, but they're more reliable for blocking water-based odors and stains like rust, nicotine, smoke, wood tannins and, of course, water (see “Shellac: The Original Primer,” below, for dealing with severe stains and odors).

Water-based stain-blocking primers offer easy cleanup and less odor and come in low- and no-VOC (volatile organic compounds) formulations. These work best to block solvent-based stains like crayon, grease, ink and scuff marks. Both versions are white, so it's a good idea to tint them gray or close to your topcoat color if they'll be covered by dark-colored paint.

Do I Always Need to Prime Before Painting?

You don't have to prime previously painted surfaces if the paint is in good shape—no chipping or peeling. Interior walls usually don't need priming except in the case of stains, repairs or a paint color that's drastically different. Interior painted woodwork usually needs spot priming at a minimum. Exterior paint takes such a beating that it almost always needs priming.

Problem 2: New Drywall

The mud used on the seams of drywall absorbs paint differently than the rest of the drywall. This difference in porosity can cause blotchy, dull areas under the paint (a problem called “flashing”) and an inconsistent sheen. Prevent this problem by using a drywall primer-sealer.

If you're an ace drywall finisher and your walls are perfectly smooth, you can use a standard drywall primer-sealer. But if you're like most of us, your finished drywall probably has some tiny pockmarks, fine ridges and scuffed paper from sanding. The solution to those minor imperfections is a “high-build” drywall primer-sealer. This heavier-bodied primer-sealer is a little more expensive than standard primer-sealer, but it does a better job of leveling and filling in rough or uneven drywall construction. (Sorry to say that not even a high-build drywall primer can hide a terrible tape job.)

Alternatively, if your drywall is relatively smooth and the topcoat is going to be a flat paint, you can skip the primer and use two coats of high-quality self-priming water-based flat paint (see “Self-Priming Paints,” below). The heavy-bodied paint resins in self-priming paints seal the surface and fill imperfections (which are less visible in flat paint anyway).

Tip: Paint within 48 hours of priming. Many primers are formulated to physically and chemically bond with the paint applied over them. Once you've primed, you should paint over it within a couple of days or it will lose its effectiveness and you'll need to prime again.

DIY Success Story
“I did a good job of taping the drywall in our new family room, but there were definitely a couple of spots where the mud got a little thick. The guy at the paint store recommended a primer made especially for imperfect drywall. I was skeptical, but once I'd primed and painted the wall, nobody (not even me) could tell where the rough spots were.”
Reed Schwender

Problem 3: Moisture-prone areas

The high moisture in areas such as kitchens, closets, bathrooms and laundry rooms can cause paints to mildew, flake or peel. Interior moisture moving outward through the wall can cause peeling, bubbling or blistering on exterior walls as well. Use a vapor barrier primer to seal the surface and minimize the passage of moisture through the walls to the outside. If mildew is a serious concern, use a stain-blocking primer to prevent mildew stains from bleeding through the topcoat and then use a topcoat that specifically resists mildew (check the label). Make sure to kill any mildew with a one-part bleach and three-parts water mixture before priming.

Problem 4: Repaired walls

Like new drywall mud, wall patches absorb paint differently than the rest of the wall. To prevent flashing, cover everything from dabs of spackle to broad patches of joint compound with a good-quality drywall primer-sealer. However, if you have plaster rather than drywall, any repairs you make will need a coat of oil-based stain-blocking primer. Without it, lime stains will form around the repairs and will bleed through the topcoat. This applies to tiny caulking and spackling touch-ups as well as major repairs with joint compound.

Problem 5: New interior bare wood

It's important to prime bare wood to seal the thirsty surface, hide imperfections and bind the wood fibers to make the surface more uniform. Slower-drying oil-based primers, such as an enamel undercoat primer, provide better adhesion and are easier to sand than water-based primers. If you use a water-based primer, it's likely to raise the grain of the wood and require more sanding before you apply the topcoat.

Problem 6: MDF (medium-density fiberboard)

Use an oil-based primer unless the MDF comes preprimed. Don't use a water-based primer, which can soak into the surface and cause it to swell. Before priming, sand the surface smooth and make sure it's dust-free. Prime all surfaces, including the board edges.

Spot-priming with shellac

Spot-priming with shellac

Shellac: The Original Primer

Shellac has been used for centuries and is still the best primer for a few situations. It's an excellent choice if you need a fast-drying spot primer to prevent wood knots, rusty nail heads and the most severe water-based stains and odors such as smoke, soot, urine and nicotine from-bleeding through the topcoat. Shellac (a common brand is BIN) can soften in direct sunlight and by itself isn't durable enough for exterior use. If you use it for exterior spot priming, prime over it with a water-based exterior primer before applying the topcoat. Shellac requires denatured alcohol for thinning and cleanup. For the best results, make sure the surface is completely clean and dust-free before applying. The photo shows spot-priming nail heads and knots with shellac to prevent rust and wood resins from bleeding through the topcoat.

Problem 7: Previously painted interior woodwork

If the old paint is in good shape, there's no need to prime. But if the paint is chalking or is chipped, use an oil-based enamel undercoat primer after properly prepping the surface. An enamel undercoat primer bonds well to previously painted surfaces and improves the topcoat by flowing out to a dense, smooth uniform foundation without laps or brush marks. Fast-drying primers like shellac and many water-based products dry too quickly and become brittle. This can cause lap marks and makes it harder to sand and get a smooth base for the topcoat. Oil-based primers sand well but dry more slowly (some can take 48 hours or longer). If you want to use a water-based product, look for a high-build acrylic-latex enamel undercoat that's specifically designed to be sanded.

Problem 8: Drastic paint color change

When you change from a light color to dark or vice versa, it can take many coats of paint to hide the existing paint color. Tinting your primer gray or a color similar to your finish paint reduces the number of topcoats you need to apply to get good results. Not all primers can be tinted darker colors, so make sure to choose one that can. Even without a drastic color change, tinting your primer gray will help enhance the color of most dark-colored interior paints and improve a primer's “hide” (how well it covers the imperfections and color of your wall surface).

Problem 9: Exterior wood

Exterior paint takes a beating. And one of the best ways to extend the life of your paint job is with a good primer. So unless you enjoy scraping paint, spend about $30 per gallon on a top-quality acrylic/latex exterior primer. Look for “100 percent acrylic” on the label, and make sure the wood surface is clean, dry and dull (no sheen). On properly prepared walls, a high-quality primer can double the life of your exterior paint job.

Tip: Use a primer and paint from the same manufacturer. Many primers are formulated to work best with certain paints.

Problem 10: Old exterior paint

If exterior paint is in great shape, there's no need to prime. But that's hardly ever the case. At the very least, you'll have to spot-prime any bare wood where the paint has peeled away. Use a high-quality acrylic/latex exterior primer. And if the paint is “chalking,” you'll have to prime the entire surface. To detect chalking, just wipe the paint with a rag. If the rag picks up colored dust, you've got chalking. Before you prime, thoroughly scrub and power-wash the siding. Peeling areas with dirt and mildew must be cleaned, scraped or sanded before priming. Preparation is the key to a long-lasting paint job. If it's not done correctly, the surface will peel again within a year or two.

Problem 11: Exterior woods that stain

Cedar, redwood and a few less common woods contain lots of pigments, called tannins, that will bleed through standard primer and paint. To stop the bleeding, use an oil-based stain-blocking exterior primer for larger areas and top with an acrylic/latex finish coat. If you're going to use an oil topcoat, use only an oil-based primer. However, thanks to new water-based paint formulations, you can paint an acrylic/latex topcoat over either an oil- or water-based primer.

Self-priming paint

Self-priming paint

Self-Priming Paints
Self-priming paints hit the market almost a decade ago with the promise of paint and primer in one can. The early reviews were mixed, but paint technology has continued to improve. The newest self-priming paints include Behr's Premium Plus Ultra, Sherwin-Williams' Duration and Benjamin Moore's Aura paints. The manufacturers tell us that these thick, high-build, low-VOC paints provide a dense, hard, durable paint film that resists moisture and mildew, all without using a separate prime coat. Prices for these self-priming paints range from $35 to $55 a gallon. For more information, visit behr.com, sherwin-williams.com and benjaminmoore.com.

Back to Top

Required Materials for this Project

Avoid last-minute shopping trips by having all your materials ready ahead of time. Here's a list.

Comments from DIY Community Members

Share what's on your mind and see what other DIYers are thinking about.

1 - 2 of 2 comments
Show per page: 20   All

May 09, 2:12 PM [GMT -5]

My owner wishes to paint my home and he said to me because I smoke I would need a heavy duty primer. I thought heavy duty primers were for only rod and metal; and not for walls.

My brother told me the heavy duty primer is also toxic. I have an auto-immune deficiency and my owner's comments on this primer worries me about my healthy and I have 2 cats.

Which primer would you suggest. He did fix the ceiling in my kitchen because the roof leaked and he has put in some new jip rock and plaster.

August 09, 11:16 AM [GMT -5]

Ok so what is a “high-build” drywall primer-sealer?"

+ Add Your Comment
closeX

Add Your Comment

Painting: How to Choose and Use Primers

Please add your comment
closeX

Log in to My Account

Log in to enjoy membership benefits from The Family Handyman.

  • Forgot your password?
Don’t have an account yet?

Sign up today for FREE and become part of The Family Handyman community of DIYers.

Member benefits:

  • Get a FREE Traditional Bookcase Project Plan
  • Sign up for FREE DIY newsletters
  • Save projects to your project binder
  • Ask and answer questions in our DIY Forums
  • Share comments on DIY Projects and more!
Join Us Today
closeX

Report Abuse

Subject
Reasons for reporting post

Free OnSite Newsletter

Get timely DIY projects for your home and yard, plus a dream project for your wish list!

Follow Us

Featured Product

Buy Now